Talk:Entity Article Template: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Wouldn't these templated entity pages become somewhat redundant with quasi-tutorial pages like [[Assaults]]? | Wouldn't these templated entity pages become somewhat redundant with quasi-tutorial pages like [[Assaults]]? | ||
Or should these entity pages be kept as placeholders until more expansive pages can be written? --[[User:Demented|Demented]] 15:25, 4 Jul 2005 (PDT) | Or should these entity pages be kept as placeholders until more expansive pages can be written? --[[User:Demented|Demented]] 15:25, 4 Jul 2005 (PDT) | ||
---- | |||
I think this template could use some improvements. | |||
* First off, it's missing a Flags section, which I think most entities have. | |||
* The entity name under the description isn't needed. The name is right at the top of the page already, and duplicating it just takes up more space. | |||
* I think it could use some horizontal rules between the Entity Data sections. I looked at [[Env_fire]] -- it looks easier to read to me. Is the Entity Data section headline needed at all? It makes the article layout and the table of contents noisier, but that's debatable I guess. The format of the keys in the template seems better though, where the whole thing isn't bold, only the name of the key. | |||
--[[User:IanL|IanL]] 11:58, 9 Jul 2005 (PDT) | |||
---- | |||
Revision as of 11:58, 9 July 2005
Wouldn't these templated entity pages become somewhat redundant with quasi-tutorial pages like Assaults? Or should these entity pages be kept as placeholders until more expansive pages can be written? --Demented 15:25, 4 Jul 2005 (PDT)
I think this template could use some improvements.
- First off, it's missing a Flags section, which I think most entities have.
- The entity name under the description isn't needed. The name is right at the top of the page already, and duplicating it just takes up more space.
- I think it could use some horizontal rules between the Entity Data sections. I looked at Env_fire -- it looks easier to read to me. Is the Entity Data section headline needed at all? It makes the article layout and the table of contents noisier, but that's debatable I guess. The format of the keys in the template seems better though, where the whole thing isn't bold, only the name of the key.
--IanL 11:58, 9 Jul 2005 (PDT)