Valve Developer Community:Discussion
For all discussion activity, see recent changes to talk pages.
Valve Developer Community:Discussion.
To add a comment, use the Edit button near the headline of the appropriate section. To create a new section, you can use the Add topic button at the top of this page.
Comments on talk pages should be signed with "~~~~", which will be converted into your signature and a timestamp.
lang and multipage
Anybody know how to transition pages using {{Lang}} to {{Multipage}}? The amount of pages (especially quite important ones) using lang has really hampered my translating efforts. Are you supposed to move all the translated pages like Category:Modding:fr to Category:Modding/fr individually and mark all the old pages with deletion. I know there's some info on the multipage documentation page, but it's a bit unclear and I'd really rather not create some big mess. --Wisdurm (talk) 20:15, 23 Dec 2023
Here's everything you need to do for normal pages (templates are handled seperately, they should ideally just be one template that uses {{Autolang}}) 1. Move the English page to [page name]/en
2. For all other languages, move them to be subpages of the base page (e.g. from Main Page:es to Main Page/es).
3. Assuming no pages link to the original language page, mark it for deletion.
4. Replace all instances of {{Lang}} on the subpages with {{Langsp}}, and if the page should have a different title in said language, instead use {{Langsp|title=[translation]}}.
5. Remove any categories the subpages are in.
6. Add {{MultiPage}} to the base page and place categories there as well.
7. If {{This is a}} was on the English page, move it to the base page. It'll automatically translate based on the language.
So, if Main Page:es contained this:
then Main Page/es should contain this (note the omission of the category):
As for categories, the pages in the category (not specifically the ones in the content of the page, but rather what follows "The following $1 pages are in this category, out of $2 total.") should be converted to MultiPage, so that the category should contain no pages. After that, just do what you would do for regular pages. --Pee (talk) 21:09, 23 Dec 2023
Sidebar translation
The possibility for translating links in the sidebar is now open, as seen at MediaWiki_talk:Sidebar. However many translations are still missing. I'm thinking we should probably put them all on some page where wiki moderators can get them from later.
I looked at all the users in Category:Translators, and it seems currently we could get (from just people on this wiki currently) translations for English, Chinese, Croatian, Finnish, Russian and Vietnamese. Amicdict states that they translate to Esperanto, however they haven't been online in a bit. There's also Fabi135 who translates to German, JacobsDevelop who translates to Polish and PowiDLa who translates to Ukranian, but they haven't been online in even longer.
EDIT: I've made a page in my user space for this at User:Wisdurm/Sandbox/Translators' noticeboard. Feel free to add translations. --Wisdurm (talk) 9:32, 15 Jun 2024
Modern and Classic templates
I'm going to replace all instances of "Modern" and "Classic" templates such as ModernConfirm & ClassicConfirm with just {{Confirm}} using WisdomBot. Feel free to tell me if this is a horrible idea. Task should be done within the next 24 hours or so. --Wisdurm (talk) 20:31, 16 Jun 2024
- The reason {{Confirm}} still directs to ClassicConfirm is because the modern variant is unable to do inline (like so [confirm]).
— SirYodaJedi (talk) 16:54, 19 June 2024 (PDT)
Central location to discuss formatting changes
I think there is a need to have a central location to discuss formatting changes. Over the years people would tend to propose changes on the talk page of a page they wanted to change, ask for feedback, get no reply and then change things, only to receive push-back after the fact which resulted in arguments and/or edit wars. If there were an easily found page to put those discussions it could help avoid that kind of stuff in the future. Perhaps this page could be used for that, but this seems to be more for general discussion than formatting in particular. -Solokiller (talk) 07:06, 21 June 2024 (PDT)
- Yes, something like the (ignore the funny name) Village pump that Wikipedia has could certainly improve coordination. I used to not be involved in moderation and proposals really, and now (that I am) I'm sometimes at a loss where a particular note or proposal would be noticeable first of all, and usually it's the amount of feedback that plays a big role.
- I didn't know you made this post hours before my last edit of the main page, for example, and I made it because I thought no one really cared and there'd be nowhere to ask...
- Looking at the Valve navbox (bottom of main page), there is a section called "Discussion" split into "Static" and "Ongoing" and the latter is N/A... what's that for, I wonder...
- Actually, I don't even know what's the shortest route to this page. I found it through edits history by accident... (edit) I see, it's called "Main Discussion Page" in the navbar, but then the title of the page doesn't match. Fun. Cvoxalury (talk) 15:36, 21 June 2024 (PDT)
- I could see a simple "Proposals" discussion page existing, although I agree that visibility would most likely be the biggest issue. Putting it in the Valve navbox would help, but I don't know how many people actually use or regularly come into contact with that, especially people who already know their way around the wiki.
- There used to be a "Latest news" box on the main page once. While I would've liked for it to exist now, not that much activity is happening where new, truly news-worthy pages are being added (it could've housed something like "Tutorial on Important Thing was added", but many core tutorials have already been added. But you never know...), so maybe its space could be given to a "new discussions" section. Not like in the link, that space's taken by "Valve technology"... maybe in top right or left, that space is vacant now... Cvoxalury (talk) 15:13, 25 June 2024 (PDT)
- I looked into how Wikipedia and a few other wikis handle this and experimented with a few potential solutions in User:Blixibon/Centralized community proposals which stem from the conversation here. One of the solutions is a dedicated Proposals page, but the others focus on making discussions more visible in general, which I've started to think is the root of this issue. While a Proposals page would help put proposals in one place, it would also be another talk page people would need to check on their own accord. Compared to a regular talk page, it might be more descriptive or eye-catching if you're browsing recent changes, but I'm skeptical of how much difference that would make in practice.
- I also wouldn't say the alternatives I'm proposing are necessarily immune to that, or that they are completely developed ideas. I'm not an expert on this subject, and it's hard to come up with a way to centralize or coordinate a community when the only definitive way to reach someone is through user talk pages. I'm curious to have more input on these and whether they seem viable. --Blixibon (talk) 11:10, 28 June 2024 (PDT)
- I'm in favour of that idea and the general vibe of that mockup. The main page, while I've been strongly in favour of keeping it more 'historical', is also in a way detached from modern practicalities (up until very recently used to reference building AAA games with Source and still references building products with it when Valve effectively stopped licensing it. Anyway...); the community portal shown in that mockup is more about what people are going to be dealing with in modding, but doesn't have a good place on the main page.
- > 'Putting the "Community" in Valve Developer Community' panel:
- Good for suggesting tasks, ironically I've recently come across *the* tasks page on VDC, now I can't find how I got to it the first time, it suggests a lot of things to do with articles
- > 'Community resources' panel:
- I never paid attention to this page - Help:Contents - turns out it even links to other valuable wikis, and here I was wondering why they're not promoted somewhere... that part can be integrated into the hub
- > 'Current ongoing discussions':
- I assume it'd need to be both automated and moderated... maybe work as a sort of pin board for people to put their discussions there themselves but be rational about it?
- > 'Bringing your work to the community'
- Can be a good opportunity not only to explain how to promote content, but what mistakes to avoid, why not write about your mod on VDC immediately, how to better use addons instead of mod pages on Moddb... likbez so to speak.
- > 'Putting the "Community" in Valve Developer Community' panel:
- To summarise, I don't really see why a button leading to a community hub like that, once it's constructed, can't be placed on the main page replacing "New to the wiki" panel. It would be within the first screen on desktop and not that far to scroll to on mobile. Cvoxalury (talk) 16:29, 9 July 2024 (PDT)
Hidden categories due to relying on templates...
There's a bunch of categories that encompass a lot of subjects but are set to be hidden, because they're 'supposed' to work by including navbox templates. (as I understand it).
One of them is Category:Source games. However, it appears obviously too short for how much it should have. And if we go to the {{Navbox}} template, it specifically warns against using navboxes excessively, so I wouldn't want to put an extra navbox/template to every game on Source in different series. Plus, which template is supposed to link to that category?
Another is Category:Games. That one's not hidden, and is full of subcats, but a bunch are empty. But what template links to it?
If it's confusing or it's a leftover from some unfinished partial redesign (some hidden categories, like Category:iOS games and Category:Linux games mention Template:Software page, which has been vanquished now)), should these hidden/template-relying categories be reverted to not be hidden and not warn people to not add pages to them manually?
Assuming that was done to not have both navbox and category appear at the bottom of the page... well, why not? Categories should be visible on all pages that pertain to them, navboxes shouldn't be used constantly - seems like that move wasn't necessary. Cvoxalury (talk) 13:47, 25 June 2024 (PDT)
- After some digging: is it the topicon (e. g.
{{Src topicon}}) template that's solely responsible for adding categories? Does it make any difference to use both it and manual category linking? Cvoxalury (talk) 16:46, 25 June 2024 (PDT)- Topicon templates are for… adding icons at the top of the page. These also add to categories out of convenience.
— SirYodaJedi (talk) 16:53, 25 June 2024 (PDT)- Then what is supposed to add pages to those "automated" categories? Cvoxalury (talk) 16:54, 25 June 2024 (PDT)
- Never mind. It appears that {{Infotable}} has the switches for the engines which in turn assign these categories like Category:Source games. I don't see why it has to be a hidden category, still. Cvoxalury (talk) 17:03, 25 June 2024 (PDT)
- Then what is supposed to add pages to those "automated" categories? Cvoxalury (talk) 16:54, 25 June 2024 (PDT)
- Topicon templates are for… adding icons at the top of the page. These also add to categories out of convenience.
can't load some pages
It seems these pages and maybe some more cannot be loaded Material_surface_properties , Material_surface_properties:ru , Es/Source , Zh/Source. Any clue what could be the issue ? Nescius (talk) 10:54, 12 July 2024 (PDT)
Any Russian speakers among the new moderators?
Among the moderators elected earlier this year, does anyone speak Russian and can handle potential conflicts between Russian-speaking users (in particular, related to translation, as it's often impossible to relay the problem without the mediating side speaking it themselves)?
P. S. Can we also have a category for moderator users? Cvoxalury (talk) 01:13, 16 July 2024 (PDT)
Tutorial/Teach how to make a Portal mod
Hello! My 15 y/o son really wants to learn how to make a portal mod. He is able to build rooms in Hammer, but doesn't know how to add in things like Glados speaking, elevators, moving stairs, etc. He learned basics of Unreal and Unity last semester, but is just starting his first programming class now, and it teaches C# instead of C++. Are there tutorials available or somewhere to pay someone as a teacher to work with him? I have researched numerous youtube videos, but am not finding what we need. He has played through countless Portal mods and loves every minute; he is eager to create his own, as he has many ideas to contribute. Thanks for your help!
Adding protection on Template:Metanotice
The page isn't protected, its used over ~9,500 pages. --N0one (talk) 10:46, 13 February 2025 (PST)
A message to all non-native English editors
Greetings, First of all, I do not want this to sound like me being a racist, xenophobe, or whatever. This is just a genuine concern of mine. I also want to note that I love how diverse the VDC community is, and I do not want to point fingers or accuse anybody.
I have noticed quite a few English pages on this wiki that have sections, or their entirety, written in broken or very awkward grammar, and looks like it was written by someone who is not a native english speaker, is not fluent, or used a mix of machine translation and manual translation. Again, while I love how diverse this wiki is and I do not want to discourage anyone trying to write or learn a language that is not their native one, and a very complicated one nonetheless, I would appreciate it if any non-native english editor writing an english page would use a grammar checking software, like Grammarly which has an extension to check grammar, to check their grammar before publishing their changes.
Thank you for your time reading this, and please do not take this as me trying to attack or offend anybody.
- Equalizer, aka the better pickaxe (talk) 13:16, 5 July 2025 (PDT)
Anubis is bugged.
This is from list of Portal 2 particles:
Internal Server Error: administrator has misconfigured Anubis. Please contact the administrator and ask them to look for the logs around: fast.
H4sIAAAAAAAA/wTA QQ4CIQwF0L2naGZP 4oSOSG/TJhUXBuxH jdx+3k8bXPsiuJsL PZo5hP54kVqjaU8N oe397WtBP5DrXif3 HWlUjlQ4Zho1RkLm kvMdt3wc2+UMAAD/ /yRdYPxXAAAA
--MrSoup678 (talk) 23:00, 9 July 2026 (PDT)
Timestamps on talk pages
Earlier this year, I tried to create a standardized format for message signatures on talk pages. The {{Signature}} template didn't work out, as its only utility lay in the auto-translated word "Talk," but the situation with the {{Timestamp}} template is different. I want to explain why I believe that using this template on the site will help improve it far more than it might actually seem.
To be clear: I am not proposing an immediate, forced replacement of all timestamps on site. Instead, I am introducing a far more convenient, robust alternative to the standard ones.
- Standard timestamps use the PDT/PST format, which many find confusing and inconvenient. In contrast, the {{Timestamp}} template uses the universal UTC format recognized worldwide and this format is also the standard for MediaWiki’s
#timefunction. - Universal translation: thanks to the
#timefunction, the output will always be a date translated into the user's language. - Grammatically correct date structures: in some languages, dates are written from smallest to largest unit, while in others the order differs or additional symbols or words are used. This template accounts for the primary date formats used in various languages and displays the final output correctly.
- Using the
timehtml tag: This tag improves the site's accessibility, as search engines better understand page structure and can leverage their capabilities; it also significantly enhances accessibility for screen readers. - Inserting dates when restoring or organizing discussions becomes significantly easier: you can enable the "2026-09-21T13:05:34" time display mode in your profile settings (in "Appearance" tab) and set the time zone offset to zero; this allows you to simply copy the full date and time format from the page history and paste it into the template, without needing to recalculate the time or rearrange/remove anything.
To demonstrate the template in action, I have cleaned up and formatted one talk page here: Talk: Making a Mod.
I would love to hear your thoughts and feedback on adopting this template!
— Max34 (talk)
- Using a template seems like an unnecessarily expensive fix for an extremely minor inconvenience. I've personally never bothered changing my personal time zone settings from the server default, despite living 4 time zones over, and I don't really pay attention to the actual timestamps, only the rough date.
- I'm not completely opposed to using <time> directly, since that's handled locally on the user's device I think. That said, for some reason, your template-based signature shows up as UTC even though I have my wiki preferences set to wiki default (which is currently PDT), so it's a bit confusing, since it's different from the timestamps on the edit log.
— SirYodaJedi (talk) 12:58, 21 September 2026 (PDT)
- This template imposes no significant load; it uses basic
#switchand#timefunctions that execute instantly. There are no resource-intensive functions or anything of the sort. - The fact that you do not pay attention to time zones or timestamps does not mean that everyone else thinks or acts the same way; this is an international site, and that fact cannot be denied.
- Regarding the differences in your settings: the
#timefunction uses the server's UTC time by default; it cannot take into account the time zone and date format you have selected in your settings. We could use the#timelfunction (local version), but it also fails to account for the user's specific time settings; essentially, it simply switches from UTC to PDT/PST (only as text) without adjusting the entered date and time. When I spoke about changing the time zone in the settings, I was referring only to cases where it is necessary to fix broken talk pages. - — Max34 (talk)
- This template imposes no significant load; it uses basic
- I bet there is not a single time when you needed to know exact time when somebody answered something in talk section. This is utterly useless change that would make pointless edits in history and recent changes. Big no for me --Nescius (talk) 14:38, 21 September 2026 (PDT)
- As stated in the main proposal, this template is strictly optional and intended for future discussions, fixing broken talk pages, or manual archiving. There will be no automated or mass edits cluttering the page history or Recent Changes.
- While an individual editor might not personally need to check exact timestamps, a modern wiki thrives on internationalization and accessibility. Standardizing dates into a machine-readable format is not "pointless"—it is a standard practice for global platforms to ensure that translation interfaces, screen readers for visually impaired users, and editors outside the US time zones can interact with the site seamlessly. A project of this scale should consider the needs of its entire global user base, not just the default server settings.
- — Max34 (talk)
Tabs in templates
Whenever I press the tab key while editing a page (templates included) it doesn't actually insert a tab character, but moves my selection from the text box to the checkmark below it. This happens to me in LibreWolf (the browser I use, which is a nearly identical fork of Firefox), and it also happened when I tried it on Chromium. However, I occasionally see tab characters in templates (such as {{delete}} and {{this is a/strings}}). Am I missing a setting, is this browser based, or are people manually pasting tabs? Assuming it is copy/paste, i feel like we should form some kind of consensus on whether they should be allowed. ―Pee (talk) 14:54, 6 October 2026 (PDT)
- This has been a problem for a while now. I used to manually paste tabs until about a year ago, when I made a forked version of VDCEditor (my version,
VDCEditorEx), which automatically adds the tabs. - --N0one (talk) 09:41, 7 October 2026 (PDT)
- Before VDCEditor, I used the standard Windows Notepad for tabs. That is, I would copy and paste.
- Tabulation is important because it makes the code easier to read, and the engine removes the tabs during parsing, which helps prevent errors that can be caused by spaces.
- --THE OWL (talk) 11:45, 7 October 2026 (PDT)
- They shouldn't be used on regular pages except for code blocks ({{codeblock}} or <syntaxhighlight>/<source>), as they are annoying to type and make pages harder to edit ({{software page}} ptsd ensues). They should definitely be used in templates, for the reasons Owl mentioned.
— SirYodaJedi (talk) 13:38, 7 October 2026 (PDT)
PHP2Shell patched
Special:Version shows that we're running PHP 8.1.2-1ubuntu2.28, which patched the CVE-2026-109618 and CVE-2026-109619 vulnerabilities (aka PHP2Shell). This concerned me a lot to the point of not wanting to edit the wiki (In fact even Wikipedia was temporarily partially down because of it), so I thought I'd mention we're now in the clear. ―Pee (talk) 10:22, 21 October 2026 (PDT)
- Yeah thankfully it was patched. Additionally this wiki also ran on MediaWiki 1.39.17. MediaWiki 1.39 had just EOL back almost a year ago (Dec 2025) and highly recommended that VDC should upgrade to newer MediaWiki versions like 1.43 LTS. --leonidakarlach (talk) 21:03, 21 October 2026 (PDT)